Spagyric Tincture vs Herbal Tincture: What's the Difference?
A standard herbal tincture is made by soaking a plant in alcohol and water, then straining the extract and setting the spent plant aside. A Spagyric tincture adds the plant’s own purified mineral Salt back to the liquid after recovering it from the spent material. In Alchemical terms, this reunites the plant’s Sulfur, Mercury, and Salt.
To recover the Salt, the Spagyrist reduces the spent plant to ash and calcines it toward white. The soluble mineral fraction is extracted from the ash, filtered, and crystallized. Further cycles of dissolving, filtering, and crystallizing refine the Salt before it goes back into the tincture.
For a full breakdown of Spagyria and its three principles (Sulfur, Mercury, and Salt), see What Is a Spagyric Tincture?
The comparison uses typical herbal extraction for context and describes the Spagyric timing and methods I use in my laboratory.
Scroll across the table to see both columns.
| Feature | Herbal tincture | Spagyric tincture |
|---|---|---|
| Menstruum (solvent) | Alcohol and water in proportions chosen for the plant. | Often high-proof spirit or the plant’s own rectified spirit. Other plant-derived solvents may be used for separate extractions. |
| Timing | Timing generally follows the extraction method. | I often begin at sunrise or at another astrologically chosen moment. |
| Maceration | Often several weeks at room temperature. | I typically macerate for at least 40 days at 38 to 40°C. |
| The spent plant | Set aside, discarded, or composted after straining. | Reduced to ash and calcined to prepare for Salt recovery. |
| The Salt | Minerals in the liquid come from the extraction step. | Recover the soluble mineral fraction from the ash, purify it, and return the Salt to the liquid. |
| Circulation | Typically strained and bottled after extraction. | I typically circulate the tincture for at least 40 more days at 38 to 40°C after returning the Salt. |
| Time to make | Often a few weeks. | 80 days or more in my laboratory. |
| Stages | Extraction and filtration. | Separation, purification, and recombination. |
| Principles in the bottle | In Alchemical terms, the extract carries Sulfur and Mercury. | Sulfur, Mercury, and the plant’s recovered Salt are reunited. |
| Serving directions | Depend on the preparation and product label. | Depend on the preparation and product label. |
| Color | Varies with the plant, extraction, and storage. | Can deepen or shift after the Salt returns. |
| Shelf life | Depends on the formulation and storage. | Depends on the formulation and storage. |
Where they’re the same
Both begin with an extraction. The plant is macerated in spirit, which extracts what Spagyrists associate with Sulfur and Mercury, and the liquid is filtered. A well-made herbal tincture is a good preparation in its own right.
The differences in the extraction step are timing, intention, and menstruum. A Spagyric tincture is often begun at a chosen astrological moment, since the instant the spirit touches the plant is the tincture’s own Zep Tepi, its first moment or birth. Many Spagyrists bring prayer and ritual to the work according to their own tradition. Some also use other menstruums, Alchemical solvents prepared from plant sources. Different solvents can draw out different constituents. In my laboratory I often extract the same plant material several times, depending on what I am working with and the solution I intend to make. I use vacuum distillation to remove the added solvent and return the recovered extract to the main preparation. After filtration, Spagyric work continues with the spent plant.
In Jean Dubuis’s words, "The spagyric method is separation, purification and reunification. It is consistent with the etymology of the word spagiry which means to separate and to reunite." In this framework, the herbal tincture comes from the extraction stage.
The Salt is the defining difference
Salt is the purified mineral fraction of the plant’s Body. It can contain potassium carbonate, among other mineral salts. What makes the tincture Spagyric is the work of recovering the Salt, purifying it, and returning it to the liquid.
I often see fizzing when the Salt goes in. Potassium carbonate can react with organic acids to form potassium salts and release carbon dioxide. That reaction is one plausible explanation for the fizz. Identifying the gas and measuring which compounds form in a particular tincture would take laboratory analysis. I compare the three leading explanations in my full article on the Salt (article coming soon).
The color often changes as well. Over the weeks of circulation a Spagyric tincture can shift or deepen in color. In my work a Spagyric essence begins as a clear distillate of a finished Spagyric tincture. Once the Salt goes in, I have seen essences turn red, gold, green, orange, brown, and even very light violet. The photo shows my Jupiter Consumable Talisman, a type of essence formulation, before the Salt went in and after it turned amber.
In Alchemy, a change of color is usually a sign of success. In this tradition, the acid and the alkali in the tincture represent what the Golden Chain of Homer calls the universal Niter and Salt, the two contraries from which all three principles descend. They unite through Mercury, the principle of life force and mediation, in the marriage bed of what we call the chemical wedding. The chemical child is the finished solution, understood in the tradition as a more evolved form of the plant.
How the Salt reacts depends on its composition, how it is prepared, and what is in the extract. In my laboratory I work with finely powdered Salt and a concentrated plant extract. I use an ultrasonic bath after recombination and then allow the preparation to circulate under controlled conditions.
Raw plant ash contains a mixture of materials whose composition depends on the plant and how it was burned. I separate the soluble mineral fraction and purify it before recombination. I advise against stirring raw ash directly into a tincture.
What serving sizes tell you
The amount listed on a tincture label depends on the finished formulation. When organic acids form salts, their water solubility can change. What that means for serving size or effects would need to be tested in the finished preparations.
Frater Albertus, who founded the Paracelsus Research Society in Salt Lake City in 1960, wrote that an extract reunited with its Salt is "more potent than either the tincture, extract, or Salt taken alone." That describes his view in the Spagyric tradition. Demonstrating relative potency would require directly comparing finished preparations made from the same plant.
Why a Spagyric tincture costs more
A Spagyric tincture can take several months to years and many hours of skilled hands-on work to make. In my laboratory the bulk of the time includes two 40-day stages, maceration and circulation, with additional steps before and between. The Salt work alone can take several weeks. It involves incinerating the plant, calcining the ash, extracting the Salt, and putting it through repeated cycles of dissolving, filtering, and crystallizing. In my practice I also use thunderstorm rainwater and dew as part of the traditional work of vivifying the Salt.
I use modern equipment at several stages. I ultrasonicate each tincture after the first extraction and again after the Salt goes in. Ultrasonication passes sound waves through a liquid and can create cavitation bubbles. I also use vacuum equipment for filtration, circulation, and lower-temperature distillation.
I vacuum filter each tincture twice. The first filtration separates the extract from the plant material at 20 to 25 microns. The work of Spagyria is to separate, purify, and recombine, so I take care to remove sediment before returning the Salt. After circulation I filter at 5 to 10 microns to reduce the remaining sediment.
I time most steps using True Sidereal astrology, which takes research and planning of its own. Every new formula goes through research, testing, and refinement before it is ready. I do the work by hand, and I spent years studying and practicing before I made a tincture for anyone else.
Is a Spagyric tincture better?
The Spagyric tradition values the return of the plant’s Salt and the reunion of the three principles. My own experience in the laboratory is why I choose this method. A direct comparison of two preparations made from the same plant would help answer how their composition differs and what those differences mean in practice. I am actively compiling research and will update this section as results come in.
One of the observations I want to measure is the shift in color. Some compounds already present in an extract can change color when the pH changes. I have also seen initially clear essences turn orange, brown, green, gold, or red after the Salt goes in. A before-and-after chemical analysis would help identify what accounts for those changes.
How to tell whether a tincture is actually Spagyric
The label and the maker’s account of how the tincture was prepared can help you understand what is in the bottle. These are the details I would look for.
- Look for the purified Salt. Labels may call it purified Salts, Vegetable Salts, potassium salts, or mineral salts. Ask whether the Salt came from the plant used for that tincture.
- Distinguish the ash from the Salt. Raw plant ash is the starting material for the Salt work. If the ingredient list names plant ash, ask the maker which fraction was separated, purified, and returned.
- Ask how the Salt was made. A maker can explain how the Salt was recovered from the plant, purified, and prepared for recombination.
- Ask how the Salt was worked back in. Recombination is a stage of the process. I describe my approach in How to Make a Spagyric Tincture (article coming soon).
- Ask about the maker’s training. It is fair to ask who made a preparation, how they trained, and how long they have worked with the process.
- Read the product directions. Serving instructions describe that particular formulation. How the maker recovered and returned the Salt is the more direct way to identify the Spagyric process.
- Ask about the source of the materials. I pay close attention to how plants are grown, harvested, and handled. When a plant grows wild in the Utah deserts and mountains around me, I harvest it responsibly myself. I also pay attention to the water, vessels, and tools that contact each preparation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I turn a regular herbal tincture into a Spagyric one?
If the original spent plant is still available, a Spagyrist can recover and purify its Salt, then return it to the extract. Bottled herbal tinctures are usually sold after the spent plant is removed.
Is a Spagyric essence the same as a Spagyric tincture?
The difference is distillation. I use the term as Robert Allen Bartlett teaches it in his Prima class. In that approach a Spagyric essence is made by distilling a Spagyric tincture, sometimes with additional cohobation (returning the distillate to what is left in the flask and distilling again). The purified Salt is then returned to the clear distillate, which can change color. I also use techniques that volatilize some of the fixed Sulfur so that it is included in the essence.
Can you make a Spagyric tincture at home?
The process involves high heat and flammable alcohol and calls for training and equipment suited to those conditions. I explain the process and the equipment it requires in How to Make a Spagyric Tincture (article coming soon).
Owen Weinman trained in person with Robert Allen Bartlett, served two years as laboratory director for Phoenix Aurelius Research Academy, and has practiced Alchemy since 2018.
Sources
- Frater Albertus, The Alchemist's Handbook, rev. and expanded ed. (Red Wheel/Weiser, 1974, first published by the Paracelsus Research Society, 1960), p. 31.
- Jean Dubuis, Spagyrics: A Practical Course in Plant Alchemy, trans. Brigitte Donvez, ed. Lenny Pedersen (P.O.N. Press, 2019), p. 76.
- The Golden Chain of Homer (Aurea Catena Homeri), attributed to Anton Josef Kirchweger, English translation of the 1781 edition (Annulus Platonis), with notes by Hans W. Nintzel, Alchemical Manuscript Series, vols. 2 and 3 (Restorers of Alchemical Manuscripts Society, 1984), Part I, ch. XIX, p. 178.
- OpenStax, Organic Chemistry, 20.2, Structure and Properties of Carboxylic Acids.
- Jim Clark, Chemistry LibreTexts, Simple Reactions of Carboxylic Acids as Acids.
